What is the first thing you do when you hear a new song or group? Today you might hit Shazam on your smartphone, then link to YouTube to watch some videos by the group/singer, and maybe then look up Wikipedia to read about the group/singer. My whole life I have enjoyed what I would call musical cartography or musical mapping. When I was discovering rock and heavy metal my cartography led me from U2 or Metallica back eventually to the Delta Blues. Today my musical cartography focuses more on sampling and one of the most intriguing examples in recent memory is the
Rihanna and Drake song "I'll Take Care of You". When I first heard this I fell in love with the background music. I love the melody and I set about figuring out what this song was about. This led me to a remix version with vocals by
Gil Scott Heron. The remix was done by someone named Jamie xx and I would assume he was the one that placed the melodies that loved. However, the Gil Scott Heron version made me realize I also really liked the lyrics and I was curious what the "original" version sounded like if Jamie xx added in the beautiful melodies. That led me to the original
Gil Scott Heron version. From here I learned that this was no more Gil Scott Heron's song than it was Jamie xx, Drake, or Rihanna's. The true original version was written by Brook Benton and recorded by
Bobby "Blue" Bland. Bobby Blue is a very famous blues and R&B artist whose most recognizable work is
"Ain't No Love in the Heart of the City", which went on to be sampled by
Jay-Z. There are two lessons I took from this exercise: first it always comes back to the blues or R&B and second that Gil Scott Heron is very amazing. He reminds me of Bob Dylan in that he was an incredibly gifted writer with an incredibly unique voice. When I compare all the versions of "I'll Take Care of You" I can't help but feel that as much as I least like the approach for the Drake/Rihanna version I think it might be the best. From here the debate rages on about what it means to be a fan who learns about Gil Scott Heron in this manner vs. an original fan. My thinking is if one arrives at the same destination their journey there, in these situations, doesn't matter as much.